Skip to main content

Here is another one. Whenever I park speedie in the garage after running it for a while, oil seeps out the breather tube which is stupidly facing down. I saw a pix on this site with it facing up. What an idea!. But it is not obvious how to turn it around without plugging the old hole on the filler tube and drilling and tapping a new one with small pipe to accept the flexible tube which runs up and archs down through the heat shield down below. Comments? Poor design corrected after 2001 when my Vintage was built?

Fred Adler
San Diego
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Here is another one. Whenever I park speedie in the garage after running it for a while, oil seeps out the breather tube which is stupidly facing down. I saw a pix on this site with it facing up. What an idea!. But it is not obvious how to turn it around without plugging the old hole on the filler tube and drilling and tapping a new one with small pipe to accept the flexible tube which runs up and archs down through the heat shield down below. Comments? Poor design corrected after 2001 when my Vintage was built?

Fred Adler
San Diego

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Clean engine 003
  • Clean engine 001
Sounds like you got a clue as to the problem. The next time you dig into the engine, check orientation of oil deflector; it's mounted between the generator/alternator stand and the crankcase. This may also contribute to excessive oil in that area of the engine. Also, check torque of mounting nuts; use correct torque.
See link below for clarity of deflector orientation:
http://www.thesamba.com/vw/forum/viewtopic.php?t=290772&highlight=oil+deflector
Fred, Scott's got a great point.
If you're going to relocate the tube anyway, you can get a drain plug at any plumbing supply house. I have a brass plug in the bottom of my breather tank; it's a keeper for a hole I'll use to dump to the exhaust.
In your case, having the tube drilled and tapped for an upward departure means you'll have to remove the filler neck anyway, so checking the plate is something to do at that time.
There's an old plug in the back of the filler neck on my car, about 3/8", where there used to be a drain line. It came from an external source, apparently, and has not been in use since I bought the engine. I was thinking of using it for the same purpose as you -- but I got talked out of it.
The origin of the oil that drips out of that tube is the spinney-around parts right underneath that filler neck. That's why the defelctor plate is there.
While there's pressure in the case, there will always be oil flung up into that deflector plate. It will always spray oil upward through it and into the filler neck, so putting a breather there will always result in oil-laden vapors trying to get somewhere where there's less pressure.
Which is also -- apparently -- why some folks vent their through their valve covers to an external tank above the highest point on their engines. In theory, the oil doesn't creep up the tubes and spit out the first hole it comes to; instead, gravity keeps the liquid oil to a minimum and it's the vapors that go into the tank or carbs, wherever. That's the route I took, but some people here have those lines running to their carb covers instead, using the draw of the carbs to pull the pressure out of the case. That vapor has to go somewhere ...
Does that help? It mostly works for the Hoopty, but there's always a little liquid oil in the tank at the end of a long day.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 101408 oil tank I
  • DSCN8256
Fred, From your pic it looks like there has been some jury rigging going on--is your neck secured with that hose clamp? If the hose clamp is not related then your aftermarket (must be better than a team of VW engineers) filler neck should be threaded like this one

http://www.machine7.com/product.php?xProd=263

Rotate the neck and port that fitting to your airfilter. If oil accumulation is still an issue-then stuff (don't overstuff) a stainless steel pot scrubber in the neck as an air/oil separator. The oil ladden air passing through the scrubber adheres,accumulates then returns as a fluid to your case.

Not as much as this but this is one man's cure;

http://bobhooversblog.blogspot.com/2007/07/crankcase-ventilation.html
"By devoting a bit of thought to the various problems involved in converting a car engine for use in an airplane I've managed to come up with reliable, inexpensive solutions, most of which can be easily duplicated by fellow home-builders. This approach is wildly unpopular, of course. Not because the engine's don't work but because Americans seem to have gotten out of the habit of thinking for themselves."

I like the way that guy thinks, Bruce. Great link!
Post Content
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×