Skip to main content

I'm done with the mechanical fuel pump.  They just down right suck. been through 3 in the last 10 years.  went with an american made one 3 years ago and its now toast.  just bought a facet electric pump but have a couple of questions.  how are you guys wiring them in?  direct to the ignition or carrera style with a switch?  what about a safety shut off in the event of an accident or roll over?    also, what about he fuel pump block off plate? are you guys using the one with a vent or without a vent?

 

Paul

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

My set-up: pump in the front, by the tank. Runs with key in the on position, no provision for ignition signal or rollover safety. Starting procedure: turn on key, wait for pump to change pitch (needle valves closing and pump dead-heading), pump accelerator several times, crank while pumping, start car. 

Pertaining to the lack of safeties: if I roll over in this car-- the pump running is going to be the least of my concerns, especially given that the fuel pick-up is a gravity feed off the bottom of the tank (which would be the top of the tank if I were upside down). Since there is no rollbar, and the windshield is firmly attached to... fiberglass, my head would likely be scraping the road like a little pink eraser. I'm thinking bursting into flames might not be such a bad thing in the event of having the shiny side down, except that it wouldn't because of the aforementioned fuel pick-up situation.

Stan Galat, '05 IM, 2276, Nowhere, USA posted:

That's a cool little controller. I will point out, however, that if you have carbs which are prone to go dry after sitting for a while (I'm looking at you, Dellorto fan-boys), 3 seconds isn't going to cut it if the car hasn't run for a week or so.

Stan, that was my first thought. It is a great idea but it needs to run a little longer.  I'm using the Facet pump that is a copy of the old Bendix blue top through a relay. It has worked really well so far. What I did have trouble with was the cheap Mr. Gasket dial a pressure regulator. The fuel pressure was all over the place. A guy told me about Malpassi regulators and I got one of those. What a difference. When you set the pressure, it never varies and solved a lot of carb problems. You can get them at CB Perf.

I'm not a fan of the Facet/Empi pumps due to their high failure rate.  A rotary $70 pump is preferable.  The Facets need to mounted in the front under the tank as they push and don't pull the gas.  I'd just wire with a toggle switch under the dash - turn it off when parked and you have an anti-thief system (thief will get a block or 2 allowing you time to lock and load).  Be sure to mount it on rubber insulating studs.

I'm not very comfortable with my mechanical fuel pump because Al Merklin won't always be around to diagnose and tweak a repair!...so I'm looking at two substitute options in my lap:

CB Performance #3193 rotary, and a Mr.Gasket #42S micro electric.

Glenn Ring comments that the small micro electric is a 'pusher' and should be mounted "up front" (under the tank?)... Greg Seitz, Wolfgang, comments that "it doesn't matter where the rotary is mounted"  (is that because it's a 'puller'?)

 I'd appreciate experienced opinions as to which of the two is a better choice. I don't mean to open a can of worms by rehashing this subject and extending this thread, so a 'private message' might be the way to advise me. BTW, I'm also looking at a mechanical pump block-off plate that has is fitted with an angled, threaded, vent. I have no idea what I'm supposed to 'vent' it to!

Many thanks in advance....Carl

 

 

Carl Berry CT. posted:

I'm not very comfortable with my mechanical fuel pump because Al Merklin won't always be around to diagnose and tweak a repair!...so I'm looking at two substitute options in my lap:

CB Performance #3193 rotary, and a Mr.Gasket #42S micro electric.

Glenn Ring comments that the small micro electric is a 'pusher' and should be mounted "up front" (under the tank?)... Greg Seitz, Wolfgang, comments that "it doesn't matter where the rotary is mounted"  (is that because it's a 'puller'?)

 I'd appreciate experienced opinions as to which of the two is a better choice. I don't mean to open a can of worms by rehashing this subject and extending this thread, so a 'private message' might be the way to advise me. BTW, I'm also looking at a mechanical pump block-off plate that has is fitted with an angled, threaded, vent. I have no idea what I'm supposed to 'vent' it to!

Many thanks in advance....Carl

 

 

Giday, Carl. First thing I did was install a Facet ( ******** ) low pressure pump after getting the car home for the first time in 2010.  Ew,  apparently we cannot say vibrat ( or )  on this forum.

It was always noisy and when I heard about the rotary types I bought one and it's been running very well ( almost silently ) for the last few years. Recently I bought another for a spare and was toying with the idea of mounting it in parallel with the existing pump like we used to do with the Facet pumps in homebuilt airplanes... ( Subaru and Corvair ).  I can't remember how much room I have under there but will get a look this weekend while changing out the rad.

Last edited by David Stroud IM Roadster D

Yeah, I trash-canned my FACET solenoid pump after five minutes for that very reason - the clacking drove me NUTS!

First of all, most rotary and solenoid pumps are "pushers", meaning that they rely TOTALLY on having a gravity-fed fuel source, because they can't (because of their geometry and the design of their one-way valves) forcefully pull fuel into the pump cavity - it must be supplied to the pump at whatever rate the pump can push it out the other end (don't fret, Carl, a 1/4" ID fuel line with even 1/2 gallon of fuel in the tank overhead is sufficient).  Some of these pumps will NOT pass fuel out the other side unless they have a gravity feed coming in the front end.

So to Wolfie's point of where you position a pump; "It really doesn't matter on the rotary pump. "  NO, that's not the case.  For EITHER most rotary/centrifugal fuel pumps or a solenoid pump, it should be mounted below, and as close to the fuel tank as possible. Also to Wolfie's other point; there is PLENTY of space on the shelf below the tank and ahead of the passenger side of the cockpit (beyond the front "firewall") to mount a fuel filter, one or two fuel shut-off valves, a rotary/solenoid pump and another solenoid pump for your gas heater (if you have one).  Trust me, I've just done it.  1/4" tubing between everything and decent clamps and walk away assured that it's gonna work.

Al Gallo installed a West Marine 1/4" fuel shut-off valve on his car (really nice, and cheap), while I used a 1/4" shut-off valve for a Tecumseh Lawn Mower engine.  Meh...  They're both gonna work.

Last edited by Gordon Nichols
IaM-Ray posted:

FYI, I had my rotary pump installed in front near the tank and it worked great there it eliminated the issues I had with the mechanical pump which were a slowly dying pump... symptoms, vapour lock, and lower top end fuel starvation. 

I've had the same Brosol mechanical pump, with "C" clips on the pivot, for 10 years and it's never failed.

 

Aircooled.net sells the same pump.

http://vwparts.aircooled.net/M...r-p/113-127-025g.htm

If you want an electric pump, get this one and mount it up front.

Rotary Electric Fuel Pump, 3.25 psi Low Pressure, 7mm Fuel Inlet and Outlets

http://vwparts.aircooled.net/R...ittings-p/rotary.htm

 

 

 

 

 

Glenn Ring posted:
IaM-Ray posted:

FYI, I had my rotary pump installed in front near the tank and it worked great there it eliminated the issues I had with the mechanical pump which were a slowly dying pump... symptoms, vapour lock, and lower top end fuel starvation. 

I've had the same Brosol mechanical pump, with "C" clips on the pivot, for 10 years and it's never failed.

 

Aircooled.net sells the same pump.

http://vwparts.aircooled.net/M...r-p/113-127-025g.htm

If you want an electric pump, get this one and mount it up front.

Rotary Electric Fuel Pump, 3.25 psi Low Pressure, 7mm Fuel Inlet and Outlets

http://vwparts.aircooled.net/R...ittings-p/rotary.htm

 

You running dual webers or dells with that brosal pump?  I've burn through 2 of those in 10 years. Latest one is a us made airtex and I think it's shot after 2 years.  

 

 

 

 

PaulEnvemo posted:

 You running dual webers or dells with that brosal pump?  I've burn through 2 of those in 10 years. Latest one is a us made airtex and I think it's shot after 2 years.  

Same pump...

Here's my previous 1904cc with dual Dellortos, around 2004

Here's my current 2180 being built in 2007.

Same pump back in 2010 when i had to have a broken diff replaced.

I can go take a picture tonight and you'll see the same pump.

 

I've installed a number of the aircooled.net pumps in other engines i've built and never had a problem.

 

Electric pumps have a number of issues such as too much pressure, noise and danger after an accident. I once saw a Porsche 914 burn to the ground because the electric fuel pump emptied the tank until the wiring melted and it stopped.

 

The mechanical pump does have it's limitation, but if you don't have a race car, you'll have a hard time hitting it on the street.

 

 

 

Last edited by Glenn Ring
Post Content
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×