Stick with the VS grill that you have. It is MUCH better quality and closer to the original than you'll ever get with the CMC grill.
Yes, the VS grill is slightly larger, but you can easily open up the hole all around for it using a Dremel tool with a 1/8" - 3/16" diameter rotary rasp bit. There's only one layer of fiberglass to go through (about 1/8" thick) and the rasp will cut through like butter. It's easy enough to tape a straight edge to the cover to keep your lines straight, too, and when you're done, the VS grill will look a LOT better.