Will, once you replace the condenser (and the points.......AND the coil) remember that the coil/points/condenser are all part of a tuned circuit that is trying to keep the current in the circuit in balance. After changing those three, run it for a week or two and then closely inspect the points with a strong flashlight (they used to sell small scopes for this purpose, but the VW distributor is so far down in there it makes the scope useless unless you remove the points to see them better). They should NOT have a peak on one side of the contacts. If they do, but it's very small (1/64" or less), I would consider going to yet another condenser (don't be a baby.....They're friggin cheap). When you find one that balances the circuit the points won't have a peak growing on either side - both contacts will look the same and the current is in balance.
Most condensers for 12 volts are made to the same capacitance value (it is a capacitor, after all) but that value is in a range due to manufacturing inconsistencies or both the condenser AND the coil - different coils draw slightly different operating current. Lower condenser capacitance makes a peak grow on one side of the contacts with use, and higher capacitance makes it grow on the other contact. The right value for your coil/points/condenser tuned circuit will balance everything out and no burn peak(s) will grow on either contact ("no" is kinda relative, here).
Once you find a condenser that balances everything, I am not an advocate for swapping it out with the points every 12,000 miles. I prefer to leave it in there (it is happily working with whatever coil it has in there) and just replace the points. Condensers usually don't slowly perform worse over time. They prefer to work and work and work until the point when they fail 100% and put you on the side of the road. THAT is why you always want to bring BOTH points and condenser along in your road spares kit. I have a set in my kit and I don't even run points!
So that's points and condenser 101 for this evening. Stay tuned, tomorrow, when we'll be reviewing "101 reasons why you should have a road spares kit (and why you should keep it stocked with more than roadside wine and a bottle opener)" another "Roadie Best Seller" by Terry Knuckles.......