Skip to main content

Hey Keith - it seems you're doing the right research in your Speedster endeavor and more power to ya. This site offers a wealth of information and experience-based recommendations. As with any internet discussion, there is never a shortage of experts. You just have to take it all with a grain of salt (as you apparently have) and sort out the stuff that's useful to your specific need and budget. Best of luck to you!

 

Welcome to the Madness, my brutha! 

Some time back I asked Joe Soltis to critique R&P vs the VW box.

 

Being center mounted there's some complicated and safety critical modifications to be made adapting an R&P, including slicing through the gas tank for two 90degree turns of the steering column. And, repair or replacing a R&P is exspen$ive.

 

Basically it's his experience that there's no R&P advantage over a 'tight' VW box on a street machine.

 

I understand that Soltis is prone to flashing triple digits on his speedometer...His opinion is good 'nuf for me.

I have to disagree with the rack and pinion assessment here.  From my experience, it is much more direct than the VW worm gear steering.  After having driven George Brown's speedster with R&P, it was so much more direct than mine with the standard VW steering box.

 

That's why I wanted R&P.  Maybe the standard VW box can be tightened up, but I still don't think it will match a R&P set up.

 

Anyway, YRMV.

I'm not really the thin skinned type, and  I've participated in several on-line forums, so I know what to expect. I didn't realize lumping all 356's together was a cardinal sin (although it was entertaining), and I've said 20 "hail Ferry's" and forced myself to watch five episodes of the American version of Top Gear as penance. Thanks for taking the time to respond, I appreciate it.
 
Interestingly, while I do love the Speedsters, I'm probably one of the rare few who would actually chose a coupe if both were present in front of me, and I had to make a choice (that's probably yet one more sin... you all should post the 10 Commandments of the Speedster community somewhere around here). I'm a huge fan of the "outlaw" coupes, and with any luck I'll be able to jump on my own build when I retire (again) in six years.
 
Thanks again
 
Keith
 
Originally Posted by MUSBJIM - '95 VS - OC/SoCal:

Hey Keith - it seems you're doing the right research in your Speedster endeavor and more power to ya. This site offers a wealth of information and experience-based recommendations. As with any internet discussion, there is never a shortage of experts. You just have to take it all with a grain of salt (as you apparently have) and sort out the stuff that's useful to your specific need and budget. Best of luck to you!

 

Welcome to the Madness, my brutha! 

Sorry Bob, I drove a 2002 IM with a rack(22,000 miles). I have driven quite a few Speedsters with ball joint VW/steering box, plus 2 Spyders with the same. Although the rack that Henry uses is good, I can't say it is "it" for steering, or any better than a well-set-up steering box. My mileage doesn't vary on this one. I am in no way knocking IM! They are great cars! Henry does a great job!

I have the IM-spec R/P steering. It's better than a box, but marginally so. The bigger advantage is an increase in trunk-space. I'm seriously considering hacking up my trunk next winter, building my own gas-tank out of sheet AL, getting a dry-cell battery, and utilizing a bunch of oddly-shaped nooks and crannies for the fire-supression bottle, etc-- and still having enough trunk-space to take along a week's worth of clothes and spares.

 

That kind of stuff would be impossible without the rack.

I can't imagine Stan buying a sports car that didn't need any upgrades. 

 

In 1990 I bought a new 1990 Nissan 300 ZX. 

I sold it three years later.

Why?

I couldn't work on it.  Everything was new and worked perfectly.

At the time no one made performance parts for it.

I got really, really, bored.

Sound familiar, Stan?

Any chance to get back on-thread??

 

You've heard an awful lot here, and the best advice given so far is to come to Carlisle and speak with these knuckleheads in person, drive several cars, meet the builders, and see for yourself.  It is a long way to come, but in the face of parting with or borrowing upwards of $30K, that plane ticket is going to seem pretty cheap.  A few personal notes:  I agree that IMs are, as a whole, the best builds, and the most expensive.  They also come in a wide range of fitments, if I can use that term, including a custom job all fit out w/ Porsche running gear head to toe, 911 power (and Subby too, I think).  Such cars are definitely NOT a VW in any way.  JPS makes a good car (Speedy and Coupe too) for a pretty reasonable $$.  Likewise Beck and VS.  If you get one new, you get to have it built YOUR way wrt trim, power, handling, color, etc.  Would you be able to know what you'd like to have along these lines? This is how I went at it w/ JPS:  found out about all the options available, made my choices, had it built. And I can attest that it is possible to get such a car with good brakes that will clamp you down in a hurry.  This should never be an issue w/ such a light car.

 

As many have said, there is a lot of variation in all of these things, and you can end up w/ what amounts to an odd looking VW (is, feels and runs like a Beetle) all the way up to a condition that I think is better than the original: faster, modern (i.e. new) components, and gorgeous.  I'd steer away from the used market, espec'y at a dealer w/ little to no knowledge of what he is dealing with.  Lots of good cars have traded on e-bay, as I hear it.

 

I sure hope you scratch your itch w/ a Speedy, as there is no better fun car, IMHO. But please know this: as a daily driver, you might find a few things lacking.  Water tightness is one, also the heat thing (unless you install a separate heater system, which is possible).  IM would claim that these deficiencies have been addressed and solved.  But there is no way around this: The cars are small, and this means they are hard for some folks to see -- folks in SUVs for example.  If you opt for tight handling, when running on all sorts of roads on an everyday commute might get a little tough on your joints. And let's just say it: these cars are not safe.  No matter how well built, there is not a lot of material between you and all the things that can hurt you. No air bags (so far as I have heard), for example. Roll bars can be added, but these are hard to do right, and change the look of the car rather much, I'd say.  There are some here that have daily driver Speedsters (not too many, I think), but for most, me included, the Speedster is a toy car.  Just the most fun ever, except when its raining, or cold, or snowy, or I have a long way to go.  They really are not made to run at 80 mph down the interstate, although you will have to do that some.  They are built for back country two lane twisty roads, and none do that better.  IMHO.

 

PS: Have any such twisty roads in Kansas, or wherever you hang out??

Thanks, this did get a bit off topic. I was going to recommend starting a new thread for that topic in a more appropriate forum. That was an interesting discussion that won't be easily found if someone searches on the topic, or would be available for anyone to read if they had just been cruising historical forum threads.

 

All good advise though, thank you. I hadn't thought about going to the Kit Car National event, but it's a great idea. Unfortunately it will have to wait until next year, as I will be convalescing from back surgery (my 4th) at that time this year.

 

My commute to work is actually about 5 miles, all of it city streets with a max speed limit of 35. I live in San Antonio TX, and we don't have particularly cold or lengthy winters, but it will get down into the teens occasionally. Summers on the other hand, can be brutally hot, at least they have been these last few years; and when we do get rain, it can come down heavy, and the streets on my short commute are known for poor drainage that results in some fairly deep "puddles". Fortunately the city is in the middle of an improvement project for the majority of those streets or areas that have historically been problematic when it rains.

 

We also have many "twisty" roads, and the Texas Hill Country is a great place to spend a day cruising with the top down. My wife and I love to go to what is known here as "Market Days" where each weekend a Hill Country community has an area established for people to sell antiques, art, fruits/vegetables, and other misc. stuff. These have been worked out so within our area, south/central Texas, they don't compete with each other,for example the first Saturday of each month is Wimberley, second weekend is Fredericksburg, etc. So it would also be a nice opportunity to put the top down and enjoy a nice cruise.

 

Anyway, thanks again for the suggestion, and all the information on Speedsters in general. Fortunately I'm not in a hurry to find and purchase one, so sifting through all the historical forums/threads/conversations, and comments from you and others all helps me to make a more informed decision when the time comes.

 

V/R

 

Keith

 

Originally Posted by Keith:

 

 

All good advise though, thank you. I hadn't thought about going to the Kit Car National event, but it's a great idea. Unfortunately it will have to wait until next year, as I will be convalescing from back surgery (my 4th) at that time this year.

 

Keith, I can resonate with the back surgery thing since I have had it (only once so far....knock knock knock) but am having trouble again.  My surgery was in March of 2011 for a herniated disc at the L2-L3 location.  I had recovered enough to make Carlisle in May but had to be careful about bending and squatting.   I had a very good recovery and managed another 1/2 Marathon in March of 2012. 
However, my problems seem to have started again but different this time.  I will soon be having another MRI since the X-ray showed some irregularities.  Carlisle is a must do for me but I'll have to take it easy; no lifting up the front end of Speedsters....bwa ha ha ha ha....as if I could.  Anyway, see you in 2014 and have a Speedy recovery.
Hoss

 

Post Content
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×