Kudos on the 996 and agreement with 90% of what you just shared. But to compare a Jag, steet car, or whatever to a high end replica is apples and oranges. It just depends on your taste. There are more than just a few Speedster Replica owners (of all brands and costs)on this forum with 911 cars, including someone with a new 997S Carrera on order. To have one, does not always negate the desire for the other. And, having owned a primo VS car that I remain proud of, and now the IM? Well, there is a quantum leap in quality, handling, etc. My IM is a true road car. Considering the cost of toys these days, my way less than 50G full-tilt-IM is a bargain. Does it make sense? No. But very few "fun" cars do.
You could argue the value of having a 996 and a VS, others might like having an IM and a nice 87-88 911 Carrera. Me? I'm happy with an IM, a nice 54 3100 1/2 restored, a new truck and something nice for my wife to drive. Gee, there was a day when having anything besides the family car and a truck was like having Ice Cream.
Anyway, to each their own.
Again, I couldn't agree more on some things you shared, Chris. The VS is an excellent buy, especially used ones that some joker drove for a season. Some of us like the IMs, some see the beauty in the VS. Neither is wrong. A 996 and a nice VS is a good combo though.
JW