@JMM (Michael) I totally agree about the paddle shift experience.
Lane, sounds like a nice car. I wouldn't buy a BMW, but they are really nice and I know you love them.
My son just bought a slightly modified 2009 Legacy GT turbo with a 5 speed.
Why, you may say? It's a STICK! He really wanted to learn. I took him a couple times in the Cayman and once in the Spyder.
I drove it home for him from Carlisle, then taught him to drive stick the next day. HOLY ACCELERATION, Batman!
It has a Cobb downpipe, full dual stainless exhaust, and a MEGA tune on the ECU. 300 hp to the ground. Goes from 80-120 like quick! He's gonna have to be careful, but he's 21 and an adult. So, his choice.
The car has 3 modes, economy, sport, and sport plus. It would be a fun car for the mountains.