Stan Galat posted:I'd feel bad clogging up this thread with an irrelevant rabbit-trail, but it's Phil's to start with so...
If we won't ask 20 year old kids from 4 to 8 schools to play an extra game to give them a chance at a national title out of fear of injury, aren't we really saying that the whole system is a farce? We feel good and justified with 12 games played for free, but 14 is just asking too much? This reminds me a the old Roman system of justice-- 40 lashes satisfied any punishment, so everybody was flogged 39 times with a whip embedded with nails and glass.
You pointed out J.T. Barrett playing on a 6-day old surgery-- I suspect he did that because he wanted a shot to be able to continue to play. I would suspect that if you asked ANY of the players on on the teams ranked 5- 12 if they would play another game for the right to a national championship, they would all want to keep playing.
A system that deliberately keeps kids at home, who want to keep playing, because we feel guilty that we aren't paying them is ludicrous. Nobody is asking the players what they want, because we all assume we know what's best for them That's paternalistic and comes dangerously close to a slave-owner mentality.
PS: Nobody likes one-and-done in college hoops, and my guess is that it will change sometime soon.
Yes, Stan: the whole system is a farce.
Football is barbaric. The science is building. Like boxing, it's got to be ended for the health of the players (as well as the fans).