Bill, This topic has no right or wrong answer. There are different locations that the sending unit has been mounted in VW engines. The important element is that you determine, independently, what your gauge is telling you. A solution that works is to buy/beg/steal from your kitchen a meat thermometer long enough to contact the oil in the dipstick tube. Check the thermometer temp at various gauge settings, e.g., gauge barely off the peg, halfway, 3/4, etc. In that way, you will know how your specific gauge actually reads. Some manufacturers, such as Berg, won't even sell gauges, including VDO, since they believe the inherent unreliability gives one a false sense of security. The real value of a gauge is one of relativity--you will know where your gauge should sit for proper operating temp., especially after you measure it independently. If it goes beyond the normal setting, shut down quickly and investigate. Regards, Jim