Exactly, Ray. 3.88 is only 94 % of 4.125 so for instance, a cruising rpm of 3,600 rpm only goes down to 3,386 which is not of value to me. My setup could easily use a 3.44 which would bring that rpm down to 3,002 and the engine would still be way up on the purported torque curve.
The way my car runs right now, I can easily walk away in fourth gear from as low as 1,200 rpm. I routinely make a 90 deg intersection turn in third gear no sweat. My first gear is so short, it can be a PIA is someone is taking off from a red light right behind me.
My choice for a new tranny would be stock gearing with a 3.44 r & p with the Rancho upgrades for durability. I don't run the car hard and nicely enough, the stock VW tranny has held up well for 49,500 miles over the last 4.5 years. I don't need to change out the tranny right now but if I did, I think this is the way I'd go.
Jack Crosby has a nice setup, can't remember his gearing but I remember it works very well for him.
Hopefully my tranny will last well over the summer and I'll swap it out and clean up some things this winter coming. Next year, Bryce Canyon will be on our way to Carlisle. ( just kidding, but maybe not if the Bride retires ).....need to get into Deadwood too.