Paul, I'd get laughed out of Dodge if I suggested this anywhere else, but a steering wheel is really a personal choice thing. In addition to being able to see your instruments, a larger wheel will make steering your car a lot easier -- and they are out there.
Every time you get into your car, it's your handshake. If you like a big, firm, leather-wrapped wheel, get one. If you have to have the hand-carved, period-correct wooden or ivory-looking banjo, knock yourself out. It's your car, and your driving experience.
If imitation leather is okay, and you don't care what other people think, a beater Grant GT wheel will do just fine. My car doesn't have a steering dampener anymore, so a thick, padded wheel is ideal for me. My hands don't ache after a long cruise; my Grant works just fine to knock down vibrations, and my instruments are in the middle of my dash, so a smaller wheel makes no line-of-sight difference.
As Spartan as our cars are, a lot of SOC folks look at the steering wheel as their crowning jewel. They get the rest of the car 'done,' and then pick the best steering wheel they can find for the look they're after. Lane Anderson (and others) have chosen other interior accoutrements to accent the wheel after installing a custom one, and the overall appearance is enhanced because the knob on the shifter matches the wheel. I'm not that into my interior because my car lives outside.
I't be my recommendation that you find a line of steering wheels that are upgradable with the same collar. You'll see what works for now, use its collar for the next one, and so be able to modify your choice as your taste develops.
That Nardi will probably pay for its replacement.