Originally Posted by hts:
From the (very) little bit I've learned on the board so far, it sounds to me that from a performance perspective, an IRS is preferred over the original swing axle, so I'm probably leaning that way.
With regards to authenticity, my thought process was more along the lines of the air-cooled VW engine vs the Subie. My father used to own an old VW bug and we all know what a unique rumble/charm those little under-powered engines make, lol.
Originally Posted by WOLFGANG - '13 CMC FWB, FL:
At one point you mentioned "authenticity" as a factor - the old swing axle is more authentic but, of course, a wide body kills any hint of it being the real thing.
I think that you will be amazed by some of the SOC members VW Type 1 and 4 engines of today. I can't make much comparison between the multiple stock or slightly warmed over VW vehicles and engines I've owned and driven over the last 40 plus years and my 2110 cc Type 1 and the other VW engines I have seen, experienced or driven in Speedsters.
Take a jaunt in Stan Galat's, Rich Drewek's or Corey's Hoopty as examples of very healthy VW engines.
To coin a phrase, "It isn't your dad's VW engine anymore!"
I think that Suby's are terrific power plants and I can see one potentially in my future, but there is nothing like a strong running aircooled German engine in a Speedster. It just sounds, feels, behaves and provides an experience you don't get with anything else.
Drawbacks? Sure, but a ton of fun IMHO