Bob,
The rack arrived late yesterday and I've only taken it out of the box. I'm sorting my car from it's Sunday arrival and may not get to mount the rack for some time, maybe even weeks, depending, so I can't really answer about the rack mounted. I don't see that there will be any problems achieving a nice looking result, with the hardware caveat below.
It is tubular steel instead of the mix of flat stock and tube that I think the originals were made with but no pieces will be lost and it's easier to clean I'd bet. The chroming is good overall - no flakes or noticably rough places.
There are two sets of threaded mounting holes - the inner set will fit into the opening and just clear the grill. So the rack will work. The outer set for mounting to the body or for other applications I suppose. Anyway it relieved me to find that the holes are spaced to allow use inside the grill on my car because that is the preferred way to do it.
It has several strap loops - they are 1 3/8" loops to Dusty's 1 1/2" straps, but I'd guess that the tight fit would aid in keeping the straps from falling back when loosened, so I think it'll work fine.
Hardware in the form of standoffs and thrubolts are provided as well as four 1" pieces of rubber tubing. Nuts seem to have been omitted, at least with mine. The hardware was loose in the box so maybe some escaped. Either way I'll be looking to better hardware for this.
Also, it has some plastic protector stuff - strips some sort of commercial molding product that's fitted between tubes for a package cushion or something. It's an ugly pinkish color. It could be trimmed up to look better as far as how the corners fit but I think I'm going to pull it all out and toss it. My old suitcase doesn't need the marginal protection this stuff might offer and it's weird looking, IMO.
All in all It's a decent choice. Like I said I'll be looking at better hardware, but what's provided would be usable.
The box proclaimed loudly "Made in China". Unfortunately there's no surprise there.