I would for sure go with the 40's. Even with stock heads and cam, ect... you should have a big increase in performance. Resist the urge to over-carb your motor, sometimes bigger is'nt better. A smaller carb will run better at low throttle positions, and have a much crisper responce to throttle. The only benifit to larger carbs would be WOT performance, where your car spends about 2% of it's life, the down side would be your car would run much worse at all other conditions. Not to say that you could dial in 44's wo work, but with a 1915cc the 40's would be more than enough carb for your engine.
what carbs do you currently have on the motor?
martin